What is the Best Form of B12 for You? banner

What is the Best Form of B12 for You?

Which B12 form is best based on your genetics?

One of the most common nutrients to consider when supplementing the methylation pathway is the proper form of B12. There are 3 bioactive types of B12 that are considered extremely beneficial to the body: hydroxocobalamin, methylcobalamin & adenosylcobalamin. Many automatically think that if you have an MTHFR defect, then you need the B12 form, methylcobalamin, but this is simply NOT true. It is important to realize that the MTHFR status does not determine the type of B12 that’s best for you, instead it’s the status and combination of genes like COMT, MTR, MTRR as well as VDR Taq. Although methylfolate and methylcobalamin do work together within the methylation cycle, tolerating one does not guarantee you’ll tolerate the other—even though many healthcare professionals suggest otherwise.

Best way to take B12 for optimal absorption – pill, shot, sublingual?

It’s a well-known fact that B12 does not absorb well. Only approximately 1-4% gets absorbed via the gut, so taking B12 sublingually is the best absorption avenue (holding it under the tongue or between the gums and cheek is most common). Consider some form of liquid or tablet/lozenge that can be sucked on or dissolved in the mouth. Holding the B12 in your mouth for as long as possible is best for maximizing absorption through the sublingual route.

Best tests to determine B12 deficiency & need

  • Methylmalonic Acid (MMA)
  • Homocysteine
  • Active B12 (Holotranscobalamin - holoTC)


If both the MMA and Homocysteine test results are high, then you may not be getting enough B12 intracellularly (even if your blood serum tests show B12 as high)


Unfortunately most medical professionals test for B12 sufficiency using a blood serum test. However a blood serum test merely indicates how much B12 is swimming around in the bloodstream, NOT what is actually getting into the cells where it's needed for use by the body. B12 must be transported and absorbed intracellularly - only there does it benefit health and kick off important downstream processes. So knowing what's in the bloodstream is only indicating how much B12 has not been absorbed or used by the body yet. Blood serum tests assume if B12 is in the bloodstream, then your body can absorb it, but that's not the case with so many regarding B12.


B12 is much more complicated, it requires specialized transportation as well as multiple conversion steps. Many people have genetic mutations or health conditions which can disrupt these processes, making it difficult for the body to utilize B12 effectively. To get a clearer picture of your true B12 status (meaning whether B12 is getting to its needed places and if you have enough of it), testing B12 levels in the spinal fluid would be most accurate. But this test is rarely performed in clinical settings.


If you are low in B12, consider one or all 3 of the active B12 forms to ensure your cells have access to the most bioidentical forms available (hydroxocobalamin, adenosylcobalamin, methylcobalamin). DO NOT TAKE CYANOCOBALAMIN!!

There appears to be a general lack of education available to most healthcare professionals regarding the different forms of B12, how each type is processed in the body, as well as its specific benefits. Additionally, many are unaware of how certain genes or genetic mutations can influence which form of B12 might be most effective for an individual. So do your homework when it comes to B12 to determine which form may be best tolerated and most beneficial for you.


The most widely available form of B12 is cyanocobalamin, but it is not very active or beneficial to the body. Its absorption rate is relatively low, and contains some cyanide which the body must process. Cyanocobalamin is inexpensive, which is why it is commonly found in multivitamins and fortified foods. However, it is not readily absorbed because the body needs to go through several conversion steps before it becomes usable. Cyanocobalamin must first get converted into hydroxocobalamin before the body can actually use it. Hydroxocobalamin can be further converted into the active forms, adenosylcobalamin and methylcobalamin for cellular uptake. If someone has certain genetic mutations, these conversion processes may not function efficiently, making it difficult for cells to absorb and use vitamin B12 effectively.

Research shows that taking B12 in a sublingual oral form is more effective

for treating B12 deficiencies than actually getting B12 intramuscular shots (and it's usually much more convenient and affordable as well).1

NOTE: Different manufacturers use different terms for tablets that are meant to dissolve sublingually in the mouth, but “sublingual” is considered a pharmaceutical term by the FDA, so dietary supplements are not allowed to 'label' using that word. However, it doesn’t really matter what term you use (chewable tablet, lozenge, sublingual tablet, liquid, etc.) for maximum absorption the main idea is to hold the B12 in your mouth for as long as you can.


BE AWARE WITH SHOTS: Doctors typically give shots using cyanocobalamin, and many may not respond well to that form of B12 (especially when given at a high dose), you may have negative side effects. Try to find one of the 3 bioactive B12 forms.

What to do if you have high B12 blood results?

High B12 blood serum levels can often mean:

  • the body is having trouble converting, transporting and absorbing vitamin B12 into the cells where it's needed for intracellular and downstream processes
  • the vitamin B12 in your serum is inactive and not able to be utilized
  • you could also have contributing deficiencies in iodine, selenium, molybdenum, and/or B21
  • and it can also mean that you’re getting a form of B12 in your diet (or vitamins) that is not converting well in your body for absorption (likely cyanocobalamin)


Ironically, this is called a “paradoxical B12 deficiency”. And it can refer to a lack of iodine, selenium, and molybdenum which are the main reasons for not being able to activate B2. And B2 is highly correlated with B12 ... meaning if you are functionally deficient in B2, it is highly likely you will also have a B12 functional deficiency.2


A few suggestions below are based on opinions from Research Studies, Naturopathic Doctors and Nutritionists ... Methyl-Life®'s Non-Methylated Multivitamin product satisfies the top 3 suggestions below and our Methylated Multivitamin 3-product pack covers 4 of the 6.

How to supplement when B12 tests are high

Be sure you remove all sources of synthetic cyanocobalamin from your diet (supplements & fortified foods)
Consider supplementing with iodine, selenium, and molybdenum which helps activate B2 (a B12 transport helper)
Consider supplementing with an active B2 form (Riboflavin-5-Phosphate) - a B12 transport cofactor
Consider taking intrinsic factor which helps the gut better absorb B12
Consider pulsing 4.5 mg of lithium orotate (2-3x per week) - helps the B12 transport
Only supplement with bioidentical active B12 forms - hydroxocobalamin, methylcobalamin, adenosylcobalamin

I know my specific COMT & VDR Taq gene details. Display the best suggested B12 form(s) for me based on that information.

Are B12 intramuscular injections best?

What type of B12 is in my B12 shot?

It’s worth noting that most doctors giving B12 shots are using the specific form cyanocobalamin, which is the cheap synthetic version that has cyanide in it. They typically give mega-doses (10-25 mg) to help those with significant B12 deficiency symptoms. However, this is not necessarily required. Cyanocobalamin has to go through a complex conversion process within the body in order to become active and many people cannot do these conversions well, so often much of the dose goes unused (even with a shot). A very few naturopaths or functional medicine doctors may be using methylcobalamin or hydroxocobalamin in an IV or shot scenario. These are considered two of the bioactive forms of B12, and they work well for many. However, be aware as methylcobalamin is typically the least well-tolerated of the 3 active forms.

What if I felt BAD after a B12 injection?

For some overloading their system with a mega-dose shot of synthetic B12 can actually make them pretty sick because because they can’t clear or convert that form of B12 very well. This can be due to COMT, MTR or MTRR genetic mutations which help the body convert B12 into its active forms for use at the enzymatic and cellular level. When these conversions don't happen, then the body's blood stream is overloaded with a form of B12 it can't use or clear very quickly (hence you feel very bad afterwards). If you've had a BAD experience with B12 shots, it's most likely that you do not tolerate or convert cyanocobalamin well (see if you can verify what form of B12 was in the shot that made you react poorly, and then stay away from that specific form if you can).

3 Bioactive B12 forms explained

What is each good for?

HYDROXOCOBALAMIN is a lesser-used bioactive form of B12 that is tolerated by many and understood to help the body promote neurotransmitters (for healthy brain function), protect against anemia (sometimes used for pernicious anemia), detoxify, manufacture myelin sheath, and much more. Hydroxocobalamin can also act as a scavenger of peroxynitrites that may build up in the body (particularly for those who may have COMT & other such mutations), converting the reactive oxidant back into methionine. This kind of "mopping up" activity can be beneficial for those dealing with headaches and/or migraines, inflammation, cold hands and feet, sore muscles and joints, fatigue, lack of motivation, memory challenges, feeling lightheaded when standing, brain fog, as well as symptoms of Chronic Fatigue and/or Fibromyalgia. Hydroxocobalamin also gets converted into methylcobalamin as well as adenosylcobalamin (or cobamamide) in the body - both are also bioidentical forms of B12 that can increase B12 sufficiency.

METHYLCOBALAMIN is probably the most well-known bioidentical form of B12 that is becoming much more available in vitamins and supplements. Methylcobalamin is known to promote methylation, reduce homocysteine, support brain & nerve health, and positively affect anemia as well as the circulatory & immune systems. While all forms of B12 are well-tolerated by many, methylcobalamin is the form of B12 that is most known for causing some mild side effects related to methylation. For some it can cause the heart to race or the body to become overstimulated, agitated or even anxious in some cases. Some may have trouble sleeping if they take it too late in the day, as it can overexcite the body via the methylation pathway.

ADENOSYLCOBALAMIN (also sometimes labeled as Cobamamide) is probably the most expensive and least-known bioidentical form of B12 to consumers. And while all forms of B12 are generally well-tolerated, clinically, doctors may find cobamamide to be the most well-tolerated of the three bioactive forms. Adenosylcobalamin helps in muscle recovery, myelin sheath repair, supporting mitochondria, and similarly to the other active forms, it also helps with anemia. According to research and clinical studies, B12 has a connection to Parkinson's and the adenosylcobalamin form particularly may be thought of as a valuable aid due to its action upon the muscles.

References

  1. Merav Jacobson Bensky, Irit Ayalon-Dangur, Roi Ayalon-Dangur, Eviatar Naamany, Anat Gafter-Gvili, Gideon Koren, Shachaf Shiber; "Comparison of sublingual vs. intramuscular administration of vitamin B12 for the treatment of patients with vitamin B12 deficiency"; Drug delivery and translational research; 2019 Jun

    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30632091

  2. Gregory Russell-Jones, Mentor Pharmaceutical Consulting Pvt Ltd, Sydney, NSW, Australia; “Paradoxical Vitamin B12 Deficiency: Normal to Elevated Serum B12, With Metabolic Vitamin B12 Deficiency”; IOMC, Journal of Biology and Today’s World; ISSN - 2322-3308; 2022, Volume 11, Issue 3.

    https://www.iomcworld.org/articles/paradoxical-vitamin-b12-deficiency-normal-to-elevated-serum-b12-with-metabolic-vitamin-b12-deficiency-91903.html

Table of Contents