How To Choose The Right Methylfolate For You
Types of Methylfolate: Folate, Folic Acid and more
Which folate or methylfolate supplement is best?
Good question!
Choosing the right dietary supplement is now more difficult than ever. A saturated market along with overblown marketing campaigns can blur our understanding of what’s good and what’s not.
Brands will often use unfamiliar jargon and visual effects to “sell” their products, ultimately confusing the consumer. Too often, this strategy is about gaining credibility through alluring claims in the hope that consumers won’t feel compelled to compare products.
Well, we’re about to clear things up once and for all by explaining exactly what makes a methylfolate supplement good, and how to choose the best.
At Methyl-Life®, we believe in helping our customers understand exactly what’s best for their health. This detailed resource will explain and compare the industry-leading methylfolate nutrients competing on the market today.
Folate vs Folic Acid vs L-methylfolate
Product Recommendations
Are you considering L-methylfolate to improve mood?
Try Methyl-Life's® Methylfolate 15 mg product.
Alternative Names for Methylfolate
Types of folinic acid that are often mistaken as methylfolate:
What types of methylfolate are available and how can methylfolate be taken?
Different types of methylfolate may be used in different products. Each type can vary in terms of its structure, which can then affect its delivery and uptake in the body.
The majority of all L-methylfolates on the market are bound to one of two major salt molecules: calcium salt or glucosamine salt. The salt molecule has a lot to do with how much “free methylfolate” can be delivered to the body.
Some methylfolates have a crystalline molecular salt structure and others an amorphous salt structure. This molecular structure correlates directly to a methylfolate’s stability and therefore also its purity and potency.
Methylfolates with a crystalline molecule structure are more potent and pure and remain so for longer due to their stable structure.
Fully active, bioidentical methylfolate is chemically represented as L or 6S. The inactive type of methylfolate is referred to as D or 6R. A combination of active and inactive methylfolate is referred to as ‘racemate’ or a ‘racemic form’ and represented as DL- or 6S/6R-.
Comparing Methylfolate Ingredients: How L-methylfolate supplements differ
There are several different types of L-methylfolate on the market which can vary somewhat in terms of their quality and effectiveness.
Factors that differentiate methylfolate supplements include:
What is good and bad methylfolate? Which type is suitable for an MTHFR gene mutation?
Best Forms of Folate:
The most bioavailable forms of methylfolate are L-Methylfolate, L-5-MTHF, L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate, (6S)-L-MTHF, and (6S)-L-Methyltetrahydrofolate.
The “L” or “(6S)” forms are chemically identical. This form is also the most biologically active and the form the human body will be able to utilize directly. On supplements, these may be labeled as:
- L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate, Calcium
- (6S)-5-methyltetrahydrofolic acid
- calcium salt L-methylfolate
- (6S)-5-methyltetrahydrofolic acid monosodium salt
- L-methyltetrahydrofolate, glucosamine salt
Worst Forms of Folate (the types you should avoid):
- Folic acid
- D forms and (6R) forms of methylfolate are exactly the same (these are less biologically active and are referred to as D-5-MTHF or D-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate, (6R)-5-MTHF, (6R)-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate). This is a cheap form that can be substituted in lower quality products.When individuals have symptoms or medical conditions linked to folate deficiency, such as anemia, fatigue, or mood disorders
- 5-Methyltetrahydrofolate- if labeled this way a product can contain the D/6R isomer form of methylfolate which would actually be considered a “contaminant” in a pure active L-methylfolate.
Methylfolate Forms: “D” vs. “(6R)” vs. “L” vs “(6S)”
Both the natural L-isomer and the inactive D-isomer of 5-MTHF have two chiral centers. However, both chiral centers in L-MTHF have the natural L-configuration (6S, αS), whereas in the D-isomer (D-5-MTHF) the configuration of the chiral carbons is the inactive (6R, αS).
Chemically speaking, the L/(6S) and D/(6R) isomers are mirrors of one another.
One is usually considered the “active” ingredient in a compound and the other is often considered “inactive”, "unnatural" or a “contaminant”.
The (6S, αS) isomer of calcium L‐methylfolate corresponds to the natural form of folate. This simply means that the (6S, αS) isomer is considered the pure form the body can use.
Any form of methylfolate that does not specify the L isomer form (or (6S) isomer form) of methylfolate may not be 99% pure biologically active methylfolate.
How stable and therefore potent is your L-methylfolate?
Folates degrade under light, heat, oxygen, moisture, and acidic pH, which is why stability is so important.
Stability of Methylfolate
Crystalline salt molecules are considered extremely stable due to their regular structure, lower energy state, efficient packing, and long-range order. Amorphous salt molecules are known to be much less stable due to a more disordered atomic arrangement, resulting in higher energy states, greater potential for atomic movement, and higher exposure to oxygen. Chemical degradation can also affect high-energy amorphous molecules.
The form type of a methylfolate salt molecule is the main difference between leading brands of methylfolate. The concern with taking supplements of lower stability is that they degrade more quickly, which can lead to potentially harmful constituents.
Purity of Methylfolate
The purity of an ingredient refers to the percentage made up of only the 6S or L-isomer. In a pure L-methylfolate such as Cerebrofolate™, 98-99% of the ingredient is made up of the calcium salt molecule that the (6S) isomer of 5-MTHF is bound to. This means it contains less of the 6R or D inactive isomer content in the raw ingredient.
When you ingest a product that is said to be ~98-99% pure L-Methylfolate, after the calcium salt, water and impurities all dissolve, 80% of the total raw ingredient amount (for Cerebrofolate™) is actually the active (6S) or L-isomer of 5-MTHF that’s available for the body to absorb.
This is referred to as the “free methylfolate” percentage of a nutrient. During ingestion, methylfolate becomes available for use in the body through a process called “first-pass metabolism” or “first-pass absorption.” Cerebrofolate™ has been tested and confirmed to have the highest potency percentage of any other methylfolate on the market.
Types of patented L-methylfolates
Cerebrofolate™
Cerebrofolate™ is superior to other L-methylfolates for many reasons.
Cerebrofolate™ is a crystalline (Type I) calcium salt form of (6S)-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (or L-5-MTHF). Most clinical studies on methylfolate so far have used a bioidentical crystalline form, Type I calcium salt structured methylfolate.
Cerebrofolate™ has a molecular weight of 497.5g/mol, which facilitates its transfer through intestinal cells. L-5-MTHF glucosamine is almost twice as heavy at 817.8g/mol, which can slow down the transfer.
Cerebrofolate™ comprises 80% “free methylfolate”, while L-5-MTHF glucosamine comprises only ~52% “free methylfolate”. This makes Cerebrofolate™ the most potent L-methylfolate on the market today. Ingesting just 1 mg of the raw ingredient provides 0.80 mg of absorbable L-methylfolate.
Cerebrofolate™ is produced in a cGMP facility which is FDA registered and audited, FSSC22000, Kosher, Halal and ISO9001 certified. FSSC22000 represents the highest level of quality and certification for ingredients used in dietary supplements. While most companies employ skip-batch testing (testing once every determined number of batches), every single batch of Cerebrofolate™ is tested for impurities and heavy metals.
Cerebrofolate™ has been shown to retain its stability for up to two years when stored at room temperature.
A 2023 study that compared brands Metafolin®, Quatrefolic®, and Cerebrofolate™ found that Cerebrofolate™ and Metafolin® exhibited superior stability and potency in comparison to amorphous salt and glucosamine salt forms of methylfolate. In addition, Cerebrofolate™ showed the least amount of change in the physical appearance and total impurities compared to other brands, as well as higher amounts of free folate levels, indicating greater potency.
One open-air comparison study by Jinkang Pharmaceutical found that amorphous glucosamine salt L-methylfolate lost 35.2% potency within 60 days. It also generated an impure compound that made up 19.9% of the total mass.
Over the same period, an L-5-MTHF calcium product lost only 0.55% of its potency and contained only 0.27% impure compounds.
The USP standard and limit for impurities in methylfolate is 2.5%. Cerebrofolate™ exceeds that standard by 3x as it contains 0.8% impurities. This makes Cerebrofolate™ one of the purest forms of methylfolate available.
Methyl-Life® is the first company in the world to provide an L-methylfolate product line using Cerebrofolate™.
Quatrefolic®
Quatrefolic® is the amorphous glucosamine salt form of L-methylfolate with a limited stability. This simply means it loses its potency faster than a crystalline-structured type would. Studies have suggested this form has a higher bioavailability than the calcium salts of L-methylfolate.
However, it requires almost twice the dosage amount of calcium salt forms because glucosamine is heavier than calcium. The specific form of this L-methylfolate is covered by a patent.
The main difference between Quatrefolic® and the calcium salt-based L-methylfolate forms is that the (6S)/L isomer of 5-MTHF is bound to a glucosamine salt molecule. This is often labeled as (6S)-5-Methylfolate, glucosamine salt.
Quatrefolic® is also ~98-99% pure, which means that 98-99% of the 5-MTHF ingredient is made up of the (6S)/L isomer tied to the glucosamine salt molecule.
When ingested, however, the glucosamine salt molecule and other non-L-methylfolate parts dissolve and the first-pass absorption rate is closer to 49-52%. This means about 50% of the raw ingredient becomes available for the body to use.
Quatrefolic® is often marketed as “the most bioavailable L-methylfolate”. This simply means it becomes available in the bloodstream faster for the body to absorb. In other words, the glucosamine salt molecule dissolves and metabolizes faster in the body than the calcium salt molecule. However, faster is not necessarily better in the case of methylfolate metabolism.
Metafolin®
The first generation of the ingredient L-methyltetrahydrofolate (L-methylfolate) was first patented and trademarked by Merck as Metafolin®. Metafolin® was FDA-notified and released as a prescription “medical food” in 2001. It is the main component in many “medical foods” today:
Extrafolate S®
Extrafolate S® is another type of calcium salt methylfolate. Extrafolate-S® is typically labeled as (6S)-5-methyltetrahydrofolate.
Extrafolate-S® is an amorphous calcium-salt form which is much less stable and tends to lose potency over time. It is L-isomer only, so its purity is around ~98-99%. It also has a similar first-pass absorption loss rate as Metafolin®, making it about 72-74% absorbable. This means that 1 mg of Extrafolate-S® equals approximately 0.74 mg of the active L-methylfolate (bioactive “free methylfolate”) that can be absorbed by your body.
However, an amorphous ingredient can lose up to 16% of its potency over 12 months while a crystalline molecule form will only lose 1-2%.
Cerebrofolate™ methylfolate is a crystalline salt form of L-5-MTHF Calcium. A crystalline salt molecule is more stable which means that it is not as likely to lose potency over time.
Magnafolate®
Like the other patented L-methylfolates, Magnafolate® is a ~98-99% pure form of L-methylfolate (only the (6S)/L isomer in the ingredient). It is also a calcium salt-based crystalline form and is extremely stable.
Magnafolate® has a ~78% “free methylfolate” absorption rate. This means that 1 mg of raw Magnafolate® equals approximately 0.78 mg of the active L-methylfolate (bioactive “free methylfolate”) that can be absorbed by your body.
Magnafolate® is similar to Metafolin®, it is also a calcium salt form, has the pure (6S) isomer, and its methylfolate type is a crystalline structure (Type C) for stability. The Type C crystallinity is patent-protected. Magnafolate® has no human clinical studies behind it.
Leucovorin (Folinic acid or calcium folinate)
Leucovorin is a folic acid analog, which means it is similar to folic acid. It is used to treat megaloblastic anemia, and the toxic effects of methotrexate. It is also given with Fluorouracil to enhance the effects of chemotherapy when treating cancers of the digestive system, or to reduce its side effects.
Leucovorin has also been recently trialed with an Autism Speaks study group.
Medical foods
Some L-methylfolate products are now available as a prescription in the USA under the classification “medical food”.
These are prescribed for people who have conditions related to folate deficiency. Examples include Deplin®, Metanx®, Cerefolin®, NeevoDHA®, Enlyte® and XaQuil XR®.
What makes a quality methylfolate product?
When comparing products, look for a CofA (Certificate of Analysis) detailing the exact amount of the 6R or D-isomer (as tested) in their methylfolate.
This should be considered an ‘impurity’ and should show up as less than 0.15%. In the CofA for Cerebrofolate™, this value is reported in our test results as undetectable.
Note: FDA labeling regulations
Supplement manufacturers are prohibited from making false claims about their products and from selling products that are adulterated or misbranded. Brands themselves are responsible for ensuring that their products are safe and correctly labeled before marketing so that they meet all FDA requirements.
However, changes to FDA requirements may be implemented by different brands at different stages. This could mean that at any given time, different methylfolate products vary significantly in terms of their contents - but their labels may indicate to consumers that they contain the same ingredients.
DFE - Dietary Folate Equivalent
From 2020-2021, the FDA implemented new regulations regarding the DFE (dietary folate equivalent) on supplement labels. DFE are the units that account for the differences in the absorption of folate obtained from dietary supplements vs. food sources.
The FDA has determined that food folate is 50% bioavailable and that synthetic folic acid used in dietary supplements and fortified foods is 85% bioavailable. The math here gives us a 1.7x multiple (50% divided by 85% gives you 1.7).
In other words, the FDA now requires that all “folate nutrients” are to be multiplied by 1.7 in order to show their “dietary folate equivalent” or basically their food folate comparison amount. Essentially it’s comparing the amount of folate you would get from taking the vitamin ingredient vs. the “folate equivalent” you would get from eating a plate of folate-rich food, like spinach. The percentage of folate found in food is lower than it is in folate nutrients like folic acid or methylfolate.
If one serving contains 1,000 mcg of folate, the product must now be labeled as 1,700 mcg folate DFE (1,000 mcg x 1.7 = 1,700 mcg). Check out our YouTube video to learn more about DFE.
So, a product previously labeled as providing 1,000 mcg of folate now must be labeled as 1,700 mcg DFE. On the other hand, a product previously labeled as providing 1,000 mcg that now shows 1,000 mcg DFE may have reduced the amount of folate from 1,000 mcg of ingredient down to ~590 mcg of ingredient.
Methyl-Life® formulas have not changed at all.Our products still carry the exact same amount of methylfolate that they always have, but the new DFE labeling on our products may suggest that amounts are much higher.
Frequently Asked Questions about types of Methylfolate:
What is the best form of methylfolate?
The best form of methylfolate folate is the calcium salt form. This is shown to be the purest form available, is ideal for those with MTHFR or other malabsorption issues, and it has been used in human clinical studies. After over 12 years of L-methylfolate formulating and expertise, Methyl-Life® is moving to Cerebrofolate™, the most superior calcium salt form. Methyl-Life® has also used Magnafolate®, another calcium salt based form.
Is there a difference between methylfolate and L-methylfolate?
No. Methylfolate and L-methylfolate are the same. However, you can get varying degrees of methylfolate quality if the methylfolate you purchase is not chemically derived with the active L isomer.
Is 5-MTHF the same as L 5-MTHF?
If the label only states “5-MTHF”, “5-methylfolate”, or “5-methyltetrahydrofolate”, it’s possible that it may be the “D/6R” inactive form or the “L/6S” active form or some combination of the two [i.e. (6R/6S) or DL] of methylfolate. Contact the manufacturer to confirm which form it is and if they can show you a Certificate of Authenticity showing the tested amount for the “D” isomer (it should be less than 1%)
How much calcium is in my methylfolate?
Most prescription products in the US are based on a calcium salt type. The calcium content percentage is approximately 8%, so even the highest dose of methylfolate (15 mg) would provide only 1.84 mg of calcium.
Over-the-counter dietary supplement products in the US are based on both the calcium salt and glucosamine salt types.
What is the best methylfolate supplement for MTHFR?
Those who cannot metabolize folic acid due to the MTHFR gene mutation should supplement with methylfolate, preferably a calcium or glucosamine salt form.
Crystalline molecule salt types have shown greater stability and potency over time. When choosing a methylfolate supplement, check the label carefully.
A good place to start is with Methyl-Life®. Designed specifically for those with MTHFR gene mutations, Methyl-Life® products are made with the revolutionary new Cerebrofolate™, tested to be the most potent methylfolate with clinically proven purity and stability. Magnafolate® PRO is another branded crystalline calcium salt form that Methyl-Life® uses in their product line.
Methyl-Life® has chosen this new Cerebrofolate™ form of methylfolate after rigorously studying and testing other leading brands over the past 12 years. Their best-selling Methylfolate range now has a loyal customer base all over the world.
Product Recommendations
Are you considering L-methylfolate to improve mood?
Try Methyl-Life's® Methylfolate 15 mg product.
References
- Yves Menezo, "Folic Acid, Folinic Acid, 5 Methyl TetraHydroFolate Supplementation for Mutations That Affect Epigenesis through the Folate and One-Carbon Cycles" Biomolecules. 2022 Jan 24
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8961567/ - James S Graydon, Karla Claudio, "Ethnogeographic prevalence and implications of the 677C>T and 1298A>C MTHFR polymorphisms in US primary care populations" Biomark Med. 2019 Jun
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6630484/ - Dominique Cornet, Arthur Clement "High doses of folic acid induce a pseudo-methylenetetrahydrofolate syndrome" SAGE Open Med Case Rep. May 2019
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6537060/ - Jeffry S. Tang, "MR1-dependence of unmetabolized folic acid side-effects" Front Immunol. Aug 2022.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9395688/ - Maša Vidmar Golja, "Folate Insufficiency Due to MTHFR Deficiency Is Bypassed by 5-Methyltetrahydrofolate" J Clin Med. Sep 2020
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7564482/ - Geraldine J. Cuskelly, Kathleen M. Mooney, Ian S. Young "Folate and vitamin B12: friendly or enemy nutrients for the elderly*" Cambridge University Press: 25 October 2007
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/proceedings-of-the-nutrition-society/article/folate-and-vitamin-b12-friendly-or-enemy-nutrients-for-the-elderly/D8C38CD6D49977957C5B098623459519 - Yves Menezo, Kay Elder, "Folic Acid, Folinic Acid, 5 Methyl TetraHydroFolate Supplementation for Mutations That Affect Epigenesis through the Folate and One-Carbon Cycles" Biomolecules. 2022 Feb
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8961567/ - Yves Menezo, "Folic Acid, Folinic Acid, 5 Methyl TetraHydroFolate Supplementation for Mutations That Affect Epigenesis through the Folate and One-Carbon Cycles" Biomolecules Jan 2022
https://www.mdpi.com/2218-273X/12/2/197 - EFSA Panel on Nutrition, "Calcium l‐methylfolate as a source of folate added for nutritional purposes to infant and follow‐on formula, baby food and processed cereal‐based food" EFSA J. 2020 Jan
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7008817/ - Dongyue Yu, Jinghan Li "Role of polymers in the physical and chemical stability of amorphous solid dispersion: A case study of carbamazepine"European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Feb 2022
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0928098721003870 - Lokesh Kumar, Aeshna Amin, "Salt Selection in Drug Development" Pharmaceutical Technology Mar 2008
https://www.pharmtech.com/view/salt-selection-drug-development - Peter Forster, "Methylfolate and Depression" Feb 2015
https://www.gatewaypsychiatric.com/methylfolate-and-depression - Malik M, Hussain A and Hashmi A, “Comparative in vitro evaluation of (6S)-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate brands: The post market surveillance for quality assessment”. International Journal of Biology, Pharmacy and Allied Sciences (IJBPAS). 2023 December 15.
https://ijbpas.com/archive/archive-single-pdf/6008